The DXP Scorecard logo
Independent Platform Evaluation
Scored on implementation experience
Not vendor briefings

Scoring Matrix

Every score for every platform on one page — 47 platforms · 10 categories · 184 criteria

Key70–100Strong40–69Adequate0–39Weak
Composite Scores
Suite Capability67⭐765260634569696451555453606060534346615762☠️39456062617167544764576657735850635054596561566161
Cost Efficiency4225624646666468416870716454736859753067664869426645484045⭐7970413475☠️22404270727466725363765853
Build Simplicity48☠️2568544848647149686871695854585967316368555439684555565965⭐7453457233644466717151676667636258
Operational Ease504169535348626849625966465550525964376463524940⭐70434852664763445865☠️32546556625151616664536159
Platform Velocity64745762545373675352666568567374546543⭐78665141☠️396256566963746259727844685462707361695975787872
Use-Case Fit
Marketing63⭐804963574652636340424536525656455037734165☠️32554362607065384564445164786242553746526365546057
Commerce496633⭐683732344555344537323551482922☠️2033363622443054406549313144424042553336383134404635505043
Intranet46442424373930343028252429335744352450262848303329⭐654043372921415634454451252932353819☠️18343528
Multi-Brand62⭐774051564741515438403334505550472350373960☠️23433460545653343955464860675638492447455643465145
1. Core Content Management
1. Core Content Management73⭐82666169557879715766746768686666☠️455354756448567467667570715965527863736562766366647361586367
Content Modeling
1.1.1Content type flexibility
⭐8887687178607880746480768072868580☠️305555826645637272728876887065508872736480787680767062656670
1.1.2Content relationships
80785857726068667258757082728078723248468462☠️30556466607871⭐865866528265706266616576646055575866
1.1.3Structured content & composition
84856872745872777260808270707675765050558068☠️3860756370847888686240⭐9070806880827371728455646868
1.1.4Content validation
7668606076557464706070747460787466304550706340626068637862⭐85☠️2560508060676076626868686450505266
1.1.5Versioning, history & rollback
76⭐86726474707886745864707264746876465558666662707270708672806870☠️458072847058765677728056687268
1.1.6Taxonomy & metadata management
84⭐884564686681807842665050728280504468☠️35727368628080666874524278556066587060744070525042747472
Authoring, Collaboration & Governance
1.2.1Preview & in-context editing
80907884647276847858648474805868765860727268☠️46638264808582707066558762847462⭐916862609082606868
1.2.2Rich text & embedded content
7078625566557576686270846073666662665458746457556660667070846260☠️42⭐8558686078766564686655686865
1.2.3Media library & image handling
72⭐9276☠️5070527682746876847274687074526062746350507462757366687264508560707070806371727760546367
1.2.4Real-time collaboration
40627650664562676252466272554240483840456052☠️3040724548555555705030⭐8835485660583844365580548260
1.2.5Editorial workflow & approvals
68⭐87486078557385824038665278685848☠️307052686862728080706863453266626476827232746071587256504572
1.2.6Scheduling, releases & publishing control
668064746662⭐858270636062☠️4270606462586462725663606862627264626664657646706452746772647764606063
1.2.7Localization model
787662555852⭐8885665470826462827666☠️225555807360578272748580825674586485846670776483787666504868
1.2.8Roles, permissions & content governance
6482604262588076645060666662686062☠️306060626357606680626664705068626274676250⭐846368646866485562
Content Delivery
1.3.1API delivery model
7882766676☠️50⭐8982786678808476787276605555857452507874728280867674638368776272787850707065727472
1.3.2CDN and edge delivery
72⭐887462663882816668588245624242664835707762☠️28357855557072357060577542787240784438528472428272
1.3.3Webhooks & events
587974526632808264465876605045455262☠️283880402832765545566150506240765460584065566058⭐8365453852
1.3.4Multi-channel output
688270606445⭐90836660627872686260646045☠️40805842428063607668745862528052755658847050627452545666
2. Additional Platform Capabilities (DXP Features)
2. Additional Platform Capabilities (DXP Features)68⭐7439555744495361324739335346484542466536583953396157655836☠️3063584058666144433448545358495760
Personalization & Experimentation
2.1.1Audience segmentation & customer data
7074227355306870701825252060283024455676287415652564657062☠️1022706225⭐82807020281836557458283676
2.1.2Content personalization
608032726035707070283030☠️25663032324560705272256238627070552830726652⭐82826828453032588264303470
2.1.3Experimentation (A/B, MVT)
6668406456☠️12646868224225125828303418227525621866255245727238206830327268644055202655⭐7668424536
2.1.4Recommendations
506610⭐742412154845☠️8121510322015121215181030153540484058608105835828584512221018125515355615
Search & Discovery
2.2.1Site search & discovery
70604074726052556845556050626262644260585072646058⭐8060807650☠️3866605262807462605462667262556860
Commerce
2.3.1Native commerce
525012151250☠️101215107012121258521225104210124572107315⭐7445451018651012451242101056621258706864
2.3.2Commerce platform integration
555750⭐60554258606038555028464845283235456032☠️25285042605855305052525840524852504828505848465256
Analytics & Insights
2.4.1Built-in experience analytics
52643560523258456664152530521528366532⭐78246022624258455550☠️121564522876686525182230536464357056
2.4.2Analytics & tag integration
58⭐88586060525855553552454542566656503866385845363552655852☠️283566553552585648403650485865585868
Multi-site & Global Operations
2.5.1Multi-site management
73⭐95667480606258825078423280564572☠️187058507430686880808072604874656674867860702872726655626472
2.5.3Translation management
58⭐88544258305858704250555048585550☠️284050585838566058606655355070455656745540684854506062505056
2.5.4Multi-brand governance
66⭐90425666385555664245403255424052☠️155550446215455270655852403556504554786825602048505250525658
Digital Asset Management
2.6.1Enterprise DAM
75⭐89524564605268662835523258404250☠️246438555528365563627270353062506260686040584542425540404556
2.6.3Video & rich media
72⭐7428305638283045382574363828303836407230253638302528253528☠️2238256428523830253030354028286038
Page Building & Site Delivery
2.7.1Visual page builder & layout composition
808860775574707470☠️25505548786076763858744572506655767885855562767060648777508245585284⭐92646674
2.7.5Managed site delivery & front-end hosting
90⭐95323684663578724668353276525274766290☠️307852503080668470423570823063448250323052683593559380
Marketing & Engagement
2.8.1Forms & data capture
70733055605025284018622522405878442862⭐8018725066156060766652157058☠️1272757252152566621850555573
2.8.2Email marketing & ESP integration
68553574583228406822422535304645247225⭐7528454566253048554525☠️1568602062505542302446451850505472
2.8.3Marketing automation
72602474421518387020301825253038224030⭐75184530681530454542☠️101255601870484530352046502538403470
2.8.5SEO tooling
72726448⭐7662404568☠️3658524566587260664876386666524872555548584574624260747072485472526270606560
2.8.6AI search visibility
587028☠️15481855325824282818524030286422522460422230504562522818583528266650422830444434⭐74425636
Platform Services
2.9.1App marketplace & connectors
82784042404578746440786556348485444832⭐8645586430385872685840☠️2858807252686266666474686470858248
2.9.5Customer identity & authenticated experiences
726825456266353842☠️2458305064605866668072286864623585655038552578⭐883068387060355258684242525272
3. Technical Architecture
3. Technical Architecture68746561635578736758646969686970685651617367☠️4247706563746569606562⭐7959786560726662656863637262
API & Integration
3.1.1API design quality
727068657250⭐9178746872788070787874624560866752☠️428065687570827562558855836466787552757262727264
3.1.2API performance
62727063554482776670687565605860625838558068☠️3738775560717073726045⭐8450776058745952576860557558
3.1.3SDK ecosystem
53626260453284⭐855052406652584046485225556340☠️18428048427459575858557755855040755035455858525545
3.1.4Integration marketplace
728257525262807364537770574282824463☠️30⭐84636048344562576660504062806765737466646068627562807253
3.1.5Extensibility model
8582685774688776826482718272909084☠️385759727360627074728265⭐923868749268836782768785787771898875
Security & Compliance
3.2.1Authentication
72⭐857062706384757262646868747575746178667672☠️48627280757973656067807175836668756870707665687860
3.2.2Authorization model
7082735276687282665665818476⭐858572☠️468055787566626885727468795265858078826066736584657055586065
3.2.3Compliance certifications
83⭐937180647082807040456468825555685072708072☠️20459276808080304880887368816835745848617377488077
3.2.4Security track record
595661695654⭐73665655386250457060604957646864☠️30307061706352645246506848676548725863666870466038
Infrastructure & Reliability
3.3.1Hosting model
74705771747355608053755274⭐82808080746553557565605579727155735273☠️405667626870588272755455806070
3.3.2SLA and uptime
67857666553685665060476862685050705850727570☠️3030806064667238647958686077723072494255637050⭐8670
3.3.3Scalability architecture
70806465705082777657667068708080685550707672☠️4057756658726770656565835279685575507265686570⭐8562
3.3.4Disaster recovery
7575625648437062505552605866727262484555726045☠️38686260746658586455⭐8042736348666456685855627768
Developer Experience
3.4.1Local development
625858477070555774578055727478808571☠️4055627148524556607755⭐887065578550766785707878686352757567
3.4.2CI/CD integration
65756051585279706255767567647878585045578170☠️3050605558756464636852⭐8252776468715966706866557464
3.4.3Documentation quality
627267676662827872658180787065697068☠️507278675262806664756480726660⭐8752797076767470687675727869
3.4.4TypeScript support
50456261602873706262428070643344684428388060☠️10207542407367⭐928258529055825840727032557455353530
4. Platform Velocity & Health
4. Platform Velocity & Health64745762545373675352666568567374546543⭐78665141☠️396256566963746259727844685462707361695975787872
Release Cadence
4.1.1Release frequency
7280776672688482687974778382808074826580795865☠️2877687179767872657585458170828284727784828484⭐86
4.1.2Changelog quality
626565677260727580657270757072767674537772635055725867767270646565⭐86☠️48756874737876707072727582
4.1.3Roadmap transparency
6272726845605563455372657558⭐80807650☠️3862625255387058627664725852626845626072707568734070727278
4.1.4Breaking change handling
65656264625576706655757065686376686361767560563872576172576065585770☠️35576466706074676268⭐858578
Ecosystem & Community
4.2.1Community size
708240383542705732425858734485823279☠️2582553640384750406453865750858254664053668455654680⭐959560
4.2.2Community engagement
656852403857675638487065674583785261☠️287460404135525245665873545070805262406864756468447084⭐8567
4.2.3Partner ecosystem
75⭐925767454877726650606264558279464247856262☠️32465755657875556368907065855656656064667278828570
4.2.4Third-party content
557840383845725235426660673870833263☠️1882584028384640406453726050807848673856627552634882⭐959558
Market Signals
4.3.1Talent availability
576840454038755242386255624261703653☠️2278554233414043405754615555806847664452527552574673⭐959560
4.3.2Customer momentum
6075567258507474454864656554616250743781705622☠️156256576869⭐836560708025705160706846677380586273
4.3.3Funding and stability
49⭐924675555088704850585857527880467974866542☠️29436556726865865562888433575552756864705268554771
4.3.4Competitive positioning
62685273554775686054646059555964506638746247☠️22226457558072⭐826066647742755758806350667579595872
4.3.5Customer sentiment
696069827258657160505876635569545858☠️378076574558736850555882676360⭐8440655050777947785573706675
5. Total Cost of Ownership
5. Total Cost of Ownership4225624646666468416870716454736859753067664869426645484045⭐7970413475☠️22404270727466725363765853
Licensing
5.1.1Pricing transparency
3532644240656068327874726252⭐9578458338826846954560355535308572323074☠️20253576807692904572953556
5.1.2Pricing model fit
39☠️18605048725460455278655055⭐907370723555484388525845464735856040306030383879626486855250855560
5.1.3Feature gating
45☠️28484058664754453866605248⭐957668625545486290485550504244925245385330483862514788704048805555
5.1.4Contract flexibility
41264534356055663062757057459282487825666533⭐953862484535359062352278☠️18323076708292853563904540
5.1.5Free / Hobby Tier
151538311072486212727267606290856655206270578820407062☠️510⭐926220582515156848828288185592522
Implementation Cost Signals
5.2.1Time-to-first-value
482870453868757858757076766853666683258278665540724043485980804240⭐88☠️22503577858350556282726060
5.2.2Typical implementation timeline
42☠️20664255667265426870717050455754⭐802575704552486842454745707542357520284068757650556075606552
5.2.3Specialist cost premium
40☠️1868404062686438726876764545524875226868413745704238424280825530722228357078⭐8535586255708552
Operational Cost Signals
5.3.1Hosting costs
523578657067827858785482585055566072288582426845855045527257825065⭐89☠️20687555886760588082587065
5.3.2Ops team requirements
55388062685785814580608258504047587825857837354082404252705285486086☠️18717555⭐885238548282428065
5.3.3Vendor lock-in and exit cost
48☠️20605548726270456875657860⭐907568792732585653406940553557805842207037415080669052825235857848
6. Build Simplicity
6. Build Simplicity48☠️2568544848647149686871695854585967316368555439684555565965⭐7453457233644466717151676667636258
Learning Curve
6.1.1Concept complexity
38☠️8664845457272427867747054615050762555785052356834564455707154304528483068707840655556⭐838252
6.1.2Onboarding resources
595068565042808168707378676048676271☠️358375574246725757725747785782854768526675726567738482⭐8876
6.1.3Framework familiarity
43☠️257265454280⭐88527663797357595256662542786360337241455266887450538235744264788442646454474552
Implementation Complexity
6.2.1Boilerplate and starter quality
584374423835707450667270636646666652☠️347465644540604562776568755859⭐8241744060757455727574687560
6.2.2Configuration complexity
42☠️1664524252606140726269616452515475226562625333753753436068794232⭐8220684068586254685368503757
6.2.3Data modeling constraints
50☠️2658515848365045586663685245606243324558406240584855535742665540⭐8045634766685854626352404063
6.2.4Preview and editing integration
62426258526246555556666865645766625258756258504358586761575268505865405654645563586870⭐7752☠️3558
Team & Talent
6.3.1Required specialization
35☠️10745742447574427466767354605252762255746050387539455358⭐827748316622544064738235656459636052
6.3.2Team size requirements
42☠️1274484552788242787676775652546283257276486236753850485480805235822065387676⭐8555726576677852
6.3.3Cross-functional complexity
57☠️2770626658438365456955726256686679336847566047685360636044716542553280616780466472827583⭐8465
7. Operational Ease
7. Operational Ease504169535348626849625966465550525964376463524940⭐70434852664763445865☠️32546556625151616664536159
Upgrade & Patching
7.1.1Upgrade difficulty
50707854484280⭐874068568242604658566935807845613582354739794868406870☠️23517558805548587576583561
7.1.2Security patching
586286556248⭐88885280538741607365666043848564464085484552824284407687☠️25768046855368708385468860
7.1.3Vendor-forced migrations
40☠️166048566225524842⭐74553348485256663738503850306836484460534460454435185556404955556150603858
7.1.4Dependency management
453880525052⭐85854280577654523532686925808242523880364756725280408060☠️20667862824838567578474052
Operational Overhead
7.2.1Monitoring requirements
53426860553584805064446442524042626536696555383875475563703867385076☠️3060714268484256666042⭐8867
7.2.2Content operations burden
45☠️2262445042⭐7257585648494854354044574252456155427250476362425048456535646647575145655054503245
7.2.3Performance management
484272606042757955785876455750526068☠️307578585838784254527145784055733448725682525057807852⭐8868
Support & Resolution
7.3.1Support tier quality
55426864644544515854606450624545705345505558☠️1855604850535548505043423855645645444255624440⭐8067
7.3.2Community support quality
60354837☠️2852355130457250604075724864306348405540524338535057583070665052387042576270456880⭐9052
7.3.3Issue resolution velocity
45346455605237525862646054624256666642534856624247405051554555484566☠️3056566642545663⭐6750524262
8. Use-Case Fit
8. Use-Case Fit55⭐673752474139485135383533425549393039423652☠️27443460495951333451474353615035433141444640464943
Marketing Sites
8.1.1Landing page tooling
70856268576655737042506650706578685240865472☠️386555647280744874725768708174488841555878⭐90726565
8.1.2Campaign management
58783379483540575532352830363538305130803763☠️22634563636760253062454175⭐824432502530384852404063
8.1.3SEO tooling
808568426469505266385562446378835876☠️35⭐87467662555562567760686078425772877268584072656780828269
8.1.4Performance marketing
6075356656524042543033☠️2225404750365822⭐82326532633052526870402870383562786940382255553862555765
8.1.5Personalization and targeting
54803380543065676822☠️20222058503528384270417220543072667664203570524772⭐907120332032628070404863
8.1.6A/B testing and experimentation
607842806020627268203622☠️1562504638221870306815602868527672382070205070⭐866032632530607674446042
8.1.7Content velocity
63806056626459756658577146625870585850805171☠️37566064687772476869456558⭐857156775855587579707065
8.1.8Multi-channel publishing
65⭐795578643555727252486555586255546248625555☠️26466265526565454852426762694846555840504835485762
8.1.9Marketing analytics integration
55⭐80507262425965625835282852455238682874285830552858656862☠️253260384368665333423038556572447352
8.1.10Brand and design consistency
68⭐8247485655506456353845355058625044456532633048456461676735586248457079704057☠️2250457580505545
8.1.11Social and sharing integration
4255323344423238474442423530454836⭐63☠️2058284525562542384245353842323738434042352842383638586030
8.1.12Marketing asset management
74⭐915341584247686448507342525248464255424655☠️35454558626864384755386160846048564845425838475359
8.1.13Marketing localization
63⭐82505850505058625252504850726254☠️206068556940555260626862455762444570815748645360485562464660
8.1.14MarTech ecosystem connectivity
688254735542566762403830323658523042☠️22⭐86356628524263687568253268684852706438474742487062556550
Commerce
8.2.1Product content depth
64⭐7548685746555568486558524870654425☠️1535574425624873407562584848555643583855524545525855646558
8.2.2Merchandising tools
477018⭐902224202052184018181655481415☠️1025222222552055366650201836562040522422151530422818575547
8.2.3Commerce platform synergy
55⭐8548784840605676405860353640452428☠️1838623618304245558063355046476032693845524025487832505538
8.2.4Content-driven storytelling
4572427048324549⭐76385060383868553430☠️1835423618453855487358354245355642483045584238386260646548
8.2.5Checkout and cart content
3850255515221834482848281822423518☠️12121528221545155528⭐6035281838382025381832222228353058525235
8.2.6Post-purchase content
384220⭐7015221846422038182018384214☠️121240202015422042205230201532302030341825182222332232444042
8.2.7B2B commerce content
52662552303022324622482535426555362232383242284228⭐773865433522456834485532323028424528☠️18403832
8.2.8Search and discovery content
555832⭐8852322845483235322838585044☠️202028284822452262407158222246474252765240362248355625465042
8.2.9Promotional content management
456938⭐794035304452324235344255523436☠️1835323728523552427046253052384155523833383835424842565851
8.2.10Multi-storefront content
62⭐75457550404852704052284255505046☠️183830405618454558527255404258425555703845572245455825485252
8.2.11Visual commerce and media
52⭐823055383535545030385235284040☠️24303528323430382845385552283838284638563830464230304235444540
8.2.12Marketplace and seller content
28⭐38183525202028262225183022353514☠️121215251822181822252528251822322822221820222222201515383222
8.2.13Commerce content localization
55⭐72455842404855583852584542726044☠️152838504530504258507252504852384655673845555245454828485052
8.2.14Commerce conversion analytics
446220⭐742625184545552818182828351422☠️1252183215431545426045151848282040553220181820404445424232
Intranet & Internal
8.3.1Access control depth
72783845586865584540524860648572683482556270626365⭐8870736075406885648082704570